| Rank | Team | Relegations |
|---|
| 1 | 1892 | Thornaby |
| 2 | 1894 | Billingham Town |
| 3 | 1899 | Chester-le-Street Town |
| 4 | 1911 | Peterlee Town |
| 5 | 1885 | Crook Town |
| 6 | 558 | Durham City |
| 7 | 1897 | Washington |
| 8 | 1878 | West Auckland Town |
| 9 | 1686 | Shildon |
| 10 | 1683 | Consett |
| 11 | 1898 | Billingham Synthonia |
| 12 | 1882 | West Allotment Celtic |
| 13 | 1896 | Jarrow Roofing BCA |
| 14 | 1887 | Seaham Red Star |
| 15 | 1675 | Hebburn Town |
| 16 | 1889 | Northallerton Town |
| 17 | 1906 | Horden Community Welfare |
| 18 | 1918 | South Bank |
| 19 | 1913 | Easington Colliery |
| 20 | 1890 | Tow Law Town |
| 21 | 1912 | Prudhoe Town |
| 22 | 1319 | Newcastle Blue Star |
| 23 | 1886 | Penrith |
| 24 | 1904 | Esh Winning |
| 25 | 1910 | Brandon United |
| 26 | 1923 | Stanley United |
| 27 | 1900 | Norton & Stockton Ancients |
| 28 | 1302 | Whitby Town |
| 29 | 1901 | Bedlington Terriers |
| 30 | 1895 | Team Northumbria |
| 31 | 1909 | Darlington Railway Athletic |
| 32 | 1893 | Ryhope Colliery Welfare |
| 33 | 1883 | Whickham |
| 34 | 1933 | Redcar |
| 35 | 209 | South Shields |
| 36 | 1938 | Darlington St Augustine's |
| 37 | 1937 | Leadgate Park |
| 38 | 557 | Ashington |
| 39 | 307 | Scarborough |
| 40 | 1928 | Chilton Colliery Recreation Athletic |
| 41 | 1931 | Loftus Albion |
| 42 | 1905 | Ryton & Crawcrook Albion |
| 43 | 1917 | Ferryhill Athletic |
| 44 | 1930 | Eden Colliery Welfare |
| 45 | 1932 | Eston United |
| 46 | 1945 | Thornaby Utopians |
| 47 | 1907 | Sunderland Nissan |
| 48 | 1941 | Saltburn |
| 49 | 1934 | Grangetown St. Mary's |
| 50 | 1948 | North Skelton Rovers |
| 51 | 1925 | Brandon Welfare |
| 52 | 1879 | Guisborough Town |
| 53 | 1903 | Stokesley Sports Club |
| 54 | 1914 | Shotton Comrades |
| 55 | 1902 | Celtic Nation |
| 56 | 1731 | Heaton Stannington |
| 57 | 1920 | Alnwick Town |
| 58 | 1916 | Eppleton Colliery Welfare |
| 59 | 2238 | Blyth Spartans Reserves |
| 60 | 1922 | Willington |
| 61 | 1935 | West Hartlepool St. Joseph's |
| 62 | 1939 | Craghead United |
| 63 | 1921 | Hartlepool United Reserves |
| 64 | 1946 | Howden-le-Wear |
| 65 | 2239 | Sunderland Albion Reserves |
| 66 | 1877 | Birtley Town |
| 67 | 1324 | Bishop Auckland |
| 68 | 1949 | Newcastle West End |
| 69 | 1929 | Trimdon Grange Colliery |
| 70 | 1303 | Marske United |
| 71 | 1936 | Auckland St. Helen's United |
| 72 | 1924 | East Tanfield Colliery Welfare |
| 73 | 66 | Harrogate Town |
| 74 | 1919 | Langley Park |
| 75 | 1891 | Sunderland RCA |
| 76 | 1950 | Elswick Rangers |
| 77 | 1943 | West Hartlepool |
| 78 | 210 | Spennymoor Town |
| 79 | 1915 | Murton |
| 80 | 1304 | Morpeth Town |